Showing posts with label Health and Safety. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Health and Safety. Show all posts

Sunday, August 8, 2010

Rugby World Cup Test is a shambles!

Kia Ora,

After the Rugby World Cup test of systems in Christchurch the powers that be are hailing it as a success, but it appears to be a shambles & that is just based on what was on the media. Not to mention the scathing report from one Australian reporter & some letter writers to editors.

First response to the security set up was astonishment. The police system was been overseen from Wellington using technology. Well that is great, but it needs to be the people on the ground who make the decisions as if you are hit by a terrorist attack.

As I have said before you have about 30 seconds to react if it is a suicide bombing.

Technology is only ever an aid & after watching that any group planning an attack would be planning to disrupt those communications. I saw this done by a commander of mine when I first joined the army & were enemy for visiting US forces. They were so reliant on the communications that they had to send a vehicle down to ask us to stop as they could not function.

The police commander was heard to say that people are not arriving fast enough. Shows he does not know his community. Christchurch has this thing that everybody arrives up in last 30 minutes.

The Venue actually have said this morning that the crowds were arriving a little more even than normal. So there is a disconnection between the police commander in Wellington & the venue in between the understanding of local quirks.

Next we are hearing that the Rugby Road worked great. It is a terrorist attack waiting to happen on the way there & it is a riot waiting to happen on way back if the local team looses.

On the way to the stadium there are greater crowds & as suicide bombers work in groups all you need is a few spread out a long the route & mingle with the crowds. Or watch where the bottle necks are & place IED's. What was noticeable from footage was the lack of security along the route.

There have been a lot of comments in last few weeks about New Zealand fans been boorish. Actually they are becoming the worst sports fans you can have. The abuse of visiting fans or players & watch out if they loose, especially in Christchurch. Destruction of property & fighting is the norm.

Much has also been made about the number of staff at the stadium in the lead up to the game. From experience most of them would not be security so that makes the claims even more laughable. To comply with international standards there would have to be nearly 400 security staff as much for health & safety issues as anything.

That might seem overkill but should say a suicide bomber detonate a vest in the stadium there will be panic. Especially in NZ where such things are thought never likely to happen & then in that moment 400 will not be enough.

New Zealand needs to wake up & wake up quick. All the technology in the world is only ever an aid. Stop looking at this through rose coloured glasses. Saturday night was a shambles.

http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Fear rules the Security Industry!

Kia Ora,

Normally I don't like to publish anonymous comments especially if they are taking a swipe at you with out the facts to back them up, but the other day i received a comment in support of what I am saying on these blogs.

Why I published them was to show I am not the only one saying this within the industry.

Also the fact that someone in the NZ Security Industry will not put their name to supporting what I say, is many want to carryout real security, but are prevented by the companies. If their name was published they would be out of a job & more often than not on already low wages they have a family to support.

Although my company has not been succesful to this stage, what I do have is the freedom to comment on the industry as I & others see it.

There is no regard for staff health & safety for most, no regard to actual security. More often than not the NZ Security Industry has no idea what security is.

They bank on the fear of people wanting to keep their jobs for information not to leak out & the fact that in NZ a security guard is regarded at the very bottom of the food chain, despite many being extremely bright & commtitted to the profession.
Although that is mainly what I have seen in Christchurch, the observations made when travelling or talking to people from other areas show there is no difference in the rest of New Zealand.

That there is the same people showing up in control of the industry shows that there will be no change until something happens like a few deaths.

The Stampede in Germany, although NZ is not likely to have those numbers yet in one place, asks the question how would NZ security or crowd control handle a similar situation. From experience I would say not well at all.

Wikileaks has let the cat out of the bag on the US operations in Afghanistan & I am well aware of similar things happening in Iraq whilst working there, but it is no different to the NZ Security Industry on a much smaller scale. The secrets it knows not only of its clients but within the industry itself would shock most people.

The Industry counts again on that fear keeping people from commenting openly in a way that will bring change.

http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

What about the Security Guards?

Kia Ora,

Today the NZ government signalled the increase of punishment for anyone attacking a Police officer or Corrections officer. Fair enough they need more protection.

But what about the Security Guards?

More often than not dealing with the same people on their own.



If the NZ Security Industry was professional in outlook it would be viewing Health & Safety as empowering to increase the numbers in line with international requirements.

It would be seizing this movement by the current government as a time to push its case prior to the Rugby World Cup 2011.

But not a peep out of any industry organization.

Their version of risk assessment is don't get involved. Well a lot of the idiots out there now do not care if you are involved or not. If you are there, they will attack in a group.



As I said in a previous blog, when a group of ten people showed up at one task here in Christchurch, some armed with iron bars.

They would of taken me on just for standing there, had it not been for a guard from another company coming across from their task for a chat & warning his mates over the radio.

As it stands there will be nothing done until guards start dying.

Oh & well done the Israeli patrol in the West Bank. Just normal soldiers, taking the mickey out of their situation. Seems, as with the NZ Navy reaction to people posing with firearms(something you will see the world over in the armed forces), that the world has gone too PC in the wrong places.

Just these days it goes over the internet!

http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Friday, June 25, 2010

The differing views of Crowd Control!

Kia Ora,

Crowd Control is topical at present with the upset by NZ soccer (football) fans on how the South African security moved them on.

Again it comes back to the mindset of New Zealanders who think that we don't need too much security.

They forget that from overseas experience, crowd control is not just there for security, but Health & Safety as well.

They also don't realize that it is in their best interests if it is carried out in a certain way.



The clip here shows a demonstration outside a foregin embassy in Iraq & although the camera work is not great due to covert nature, it does show that how well crowd control can be achieved even by a force that doesn't appear well trained.

Having the security armed does help as less arguments, but it doesn't stop them using other skills to keep the crowds in check.

At one point the crowd started to get quite agitated once all groups marching were on site, so to keep them happy three of those in camouflage scaled the embassy & ripped down the foreign flag.

It worked because shortly after the crowd dispersed.



More often than most New Zealanders realize the requirements for a riot are in place. In fact I would say on several occassions each weekend in Christchurch alone.

But yet again the NZ mindset says common sense should prevail & we do not need too much security & no one should be allowed to interfere with our 'rights'.

More often than not the rights they talk about are the breaking of the law.

They can also not expect the low standards of crowd control to be practised when they attend overseas sporting events. It is NZ that has to come up to standard not the world come down to New Zealands level.

http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Friday, June 18, 2010

What is Close Protections (Bodyguards) duties?

Kia Ora,

Well the big news today is the manhandling by the Chinese Vice Presidents Close Protection team of the Green Party leader who was staging a protest at the entrance to the New Zealand Parliament.

So what are really the duties that Close Protection are required to carry out?

In the movies it is always to give your life for someone, but in reality there is more than that & really what use is a bodyguard if they are dead? Body cover is a drill, but it is not just what you are there for & why more often than not your contract calls you a consultant.

There are three duties for a Close Protection team to consider.

First is the Preventing of Unintentional harm or injury.

So that means, if the 'Angry Man' is still reading, carrying out health & safety risk assessments both prior & during any moves, visits or in general, often without any prior visits. It also entails you knowing any medical conditions your client might have & have an understanding of local customs & laws that could put your client(known as a principal) in danger.

Next is Preventing Embarrassing Situations. Now todays incident can be seen two ways.

The team has brought the Vice President embarrassment by making it a media circus.

But that is the western view. The Chinese will have a very different view & whilst no expert on Chinese views, having learnt some Putonghua (standard Chinese) a few years ago which included some insight into the culture, they may view it very differently.

To the Chinese saving face is very big & having that flag shoved in the proximity of the Vice President could be seen as a loss of face. I thought their use of an umbrella was good & an attempt to show they are trying to fit in with western views.

The third duty is to Prevent Intentional Harm & Injury.

On the TV footage shown it would appear that the Green MP got far too close for the team to be comfortable.

New Zealanders have to realize that what might seem safe here is not what people overseas are used too.

I have meet some who refuse to come to NZ, as they think it is too unsafe as our police & security are unarmed.

As a country we are very reliant on amongst other things tourists coming here.

In an article yesterday it was commented on that quite a few foreign Heads of State are expected for the Rugby World Cup 2011. Just one we might be able to cater for but there has being a vast change in possible threat since APEC 1999 here.

Had this protest happened overseas it would of likely being much more controlled as indicated by the video clips that should be added below.

     http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Monday, May 31, 2010

The Wrong Mindset!

Kia Ora,

With the on going bad weather it seemed to at least in my area cut down incidents.

But some of the things going on this last week showed how little New Zealanders actually have a culture of risk assesment.

Of all the cultures in the world the worst I come across in this respect is everytime I return home. It seems to be getting worse.

The mindset is totally wrong in this country. What we see time & time again in security is that people seem to think those warning signs are for everybody but them.

The incidents this week were people ignored road closed signs, removed or moved them was just idiotic, even having to result in the police in arresting one person at least.

We often joke that if it was ten foot high neon & flashing, Kiwis would still think it is for everyone else but them.

It is not just a one off either. We see it on our roads were nice quiet people take undue risks.

The following two incidents probably best give the attitude to safety & the mindset of New Zealanders to their health & safety as well as that of those they supposedly care about.

Twenty minutes was all that was between these two incidents.

Based in a fenced area where fireworks were to be set up (they were on site) with signs on the fences saying explosives keep out.

The first incident just blew me away. A couple with two children aged about 3 or 4 moved the end of the fence & entered the area.

When challenged  the response was the standard "use some commonsense you idiot, it is the shortest route". There was the question asked as if they were fit parents to be bringing young children into an area signposted as dangerous.

The second incident was four 20 something's with two males & two females climbing the fence.

Again challenged, again the same answer. When it was pointed out that they had climbed a fence with signs saying "Explosives! Keep Out!" Their response was "where didn't see one?" "You climbed over one."

From there their reaction was again normal Kiwi. It was your fault & we are going to smash you & keep going anyway. Just happened to be their bad day as at the end of the area there was a security briefing in progress combined with police elements.

Now we all do silly things at times, but there needs to be a huge change in mindset.

But that mindset comes back to why it is so hard for the NZ security industry to actually carryout a true risk assessment for events such as the Rugby World Cup 2011.

It is also why it is hard to convince the industry to adopt a risk assessment culture that is dynamic & on going as they walk into situations.

It does not mean we don't do anything.  If we did risk assessment in the way NZ does we would of never gone out on task in Iraq. There was a risk, we knew it, but by again having that dynamic risk assessment as we moved along, you mitigated your risk.

                                         http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Saturday, May 22, 2010

How do you use Standard Operating Procedures(SOP's)?

Kia Ora,

So if you have them "How do you use Standard Operating Procedures?" & in that mix is why?

This comes back to the remark I made in the previous blog about my civilian counterparts commenting on how fast I thought.

At that site it all come down to their experience as there was no training given (& still isn't from comments of people there, training consisted of two days orientation)  & there were no SOP's.

I have said it before in these blogs an SOP is a guideline, not something that must always be adhered to as they do not fit every situation.

It was a point made to me by an ex army comrade at this complex & also came up more recently in the review of the Stanmore Road shooting by the police officer involved. The officer was criticized for not following SOP's.

A SOP is formed based on experience (theres that word again) for given situations, but will not cover every situation.

But by basing your training on them or even just having them & ensuring they are understood puts your staff way ahead of the rest.

That was why it appears at times when things are going real bad that  former military or police think faster than their civilian counterparts. In most NZ security companies they have no SOP's, so in lieu of that I know ex military personal come up with their own & each time they face a situation they formulate their own adhoc SOP's for similar situations.

When a situation is fast moving,those used to an SOP or that actually have them in place will automatically in their mind have gone through the steps & coming to say step four think, it doesn't fit this situation so next? The mind is already working & possible solutions are presenting themselves, where as those without them if they have never encountered such a situation will still be thinking of step one.

So this then comes back to what my ex army comrade said & the reaction to the police officer using his weapon.

My mates comment was we don't want SOP's here as they don't understand how they work & will make them  the bottom line.

You see that report on the police officer using his firearm. As an experienced police officer he has used his experience listening to what came over the radio & put himself in a position to be nearby if requried.


Because the individual in question was known to be using a type of weapon ( a hammer) the officer has obviously thought of  worst case scenario & armed himself. Not been prepared to order his officers to do something he himself is not prepared to do.

It also comes into question over risk assessment & his health & safety responsibilities.
As a police officer his duty is to protect the public & with no Tasers available at the time, he had to be prepared to use what was at his disposal.

He is said to have broken two SOP's, not informing Police comms where he was & not informing them he was arming himself.

So they are trying to make a SOP a bottom line & taking away the ability of those on the ground of making a decision based on factors in front of them.

It also flies in the face of facts.

Fact is criminals listen to the police radio & it is only recently that the police have started to use secure communications.

There used to be in Christchurch a well known police dog handler (happens to be ex army, equally well known in part for shooting the Tiger, although he claims it was his twin brother) who was well known for his trick of continually asking comms for directions to the place he was needed. He did this because he knew criminals listened in & more than one was surprised by a dog unit pulling up that was allegedly still some distance away.

Good training & SOP's can also have a great effect when  team works well together with little communication. People can form what in business is refered to as a master mind, where the combined minds seem to think as one.

The two times that really stick out for me was in the army during training although I did also experience it in Iraq & at times here in NZ in security.

In the first instance not a word was said as I turned to give a command as a situation developed it was obvious all were thinking the same & from the enemy party during debrief, who were thinking they were about to surprise someone else, got the shock of their lives when 8 of us appeared on their flank.

In the second incident it involved four words(his name & yeah got it) between myself & another section commander whom I had worked with over the years. But because our sections understood us, that was all it needed. Again the enemy party said they were totally surprised. From a health & safety aspect though a third party who shouldn't of taken action, did & in reality were probably shot by friendly fire.

That last part I find with many security groups in NZ. It is a common comment heard from ex military about these groups is they don't know team work & you don't feel safe.

It is not uncommon to have a situation develop where every other security person seems to be avoiding looking to back you, compared to the military where everyone backs you.

It comes down to health & safety again.

So in answer to the 'angry man' I am well qualified to comment on these areas thanks to superior training, experience, some common sense, knowledge & the fact I work in the industry & see how bad it is. I also see what has to be done & have the vision to see opportunities. 

Those factors outweigh any formal course or piece of paper. A blog is an opinion, mine is based on facts, common sense, experience & anybody can have an opinion.

Or as they say opinions are like rear ends everyone has one, some people just are one. Seems to me this person is trying to restrict my legal rights of freedom of speech.

I will answer his comments about my comments as to financial issues on one of those blogs.

    http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

How do you practice Health & Safety?

Kia Ora,

To the next part of the issues raised by the angry man's emails is basically "How do you practice Health & Safety?"

He asks what are my systems for health & safety? Also having no qualification does not entitle me to comment on health & safety issues. That is probably the crux of the issue there.

This individual dimisses my experience from the military, in the  NZ security industry & work in Iraq.

Health & safety especially in a service like security does not rely just on a system. In fact due to nature of the work carried out by the profession what is more important is Common Sense coupled with Experience (not a bit of paper or formal course) & a culture of dynamic Risk Assessment.

The type of Risk Assessment you get trained to carryout in the NZ military. From early days young soldiers get told "as you move along look for places to take cover if such & such happens" it is a type of Risk Assessment.

Initially though young soldiers are more concerned about how hard the physical requirements are, but as time goes by  those sort of  actions become second nature.

They then add in actions like looking for possible booby traps when moving whilst carrying up to 100kg plus packs without having to go through the whole process consciously.

So does this transfer to the civilian environment? Yes!

In fact, & I will go into this more in a later blog, at times other security personal have said "I think so fast", it is not that, but my military training kicking in when situations call for it, which often means when confronted with an issue they have never confronted before. 

Encyclopedia of Occupational Health and Safety - CD-Rom

With inadeaquate training or awaremess of health & saftey instinctively, my civilian counterparts are still thinking of the first step whilst myself & army comrades are already on step four or higher. So it appears to them that we are thinking very fast.

An example of the level of military training over what the industry provides was an incident early in my time in the industry.

I was on duty in a complex when I was paged to reception & handed a small case. Apparently someone was concerned it had been sitting in the middle of reception for three hours. Of course from the staff reaction it appeared they thought it was a bomb. Straight away I knew there was one type of bomb it wasn't.

When I was relieved a few hours later by another ex military person, his first reaction was "you didn't call the bomb squad?". No, because of our superior training as soon as I was handed it the check list we used to use in the army popped right into my head.

As I walked outside with the case, I ran through it & realized there was no way this was a bomb. The only mistake I made was opening in view of the staff, from a health & safety point of view which was not good.

That staff still thought it was a bomb was shown by fact that even though it was dark t they were watching & as I opened it, were seen to dive under the counter.

From there another difference came out between a person with a military background to those without. Not for the first time after an incident that worked out well, my civilian counterparts could not work out why myself or any military person would then look to learn from lessons & improve our performance for the next time.


Whilst in Iraq this dynamic way of looking at things was to the fore as the whole situation & threats were ever changing your risk assessment was also dynamic. It was health & safety at its extreme. But again that good training kicked in without much fuss.

Security in NZ requires much the same thinking as any Standard Operating Procedures will not cover all contingencies. Thats if the company has them.

During my initial NZQA security course (a well run one with plenty of hands on training unlike most courses) the question was asked of an OSH inspector as to where security fitted in since much of the industries work fell outside OSH at that time. Also that many places had procedures but no body actually knew what they were.

The reply was that is correct, but security's role was to identify hazards as encountered & report them.  They then directed their reply to me & said as ex army you know the drills if there is an accident happens during live firing? Yes of course. Well that is the OSH procedure for an accident.

More recently an incident involving an associtated industry responding to a call out & a serious accident occuring due to the fact that like security they entered a business without prior knowledge of it.

After discussion with a Health & Safety officer from the department of Labour at a business seminar, I was asked would I be interested in joining a group looking at this issue. To date though nothing has come of it.

But the discussion  had been about how the military teach you, as I said in the beginning to have a dynamic risk assessment culture,  this is what they felt they needed to install in industries who respond to premises they don't usually visit or are not fully aware of all dangers.

This culture far outways any system or piece of paper, although in conjunction with a system can be very robust.

Due to time contraints it is not unusual, in fact most common place to see security racing from one premises to another without slowing to take in account as to risks they maybe rushing too.

Someone who worked security in Australia once told me a story about their first night alone. They were rushing due to time, came around a corner to be confronted by three pers wanting his firearm. He hadn't yet being issued  or been able to obtain one.

It reminded me what I often see with NZ security racing around corners to you don't know what.

My assessments of the security situation here in NZ is based on security knowledge, experience & risk assessment.

I have often been told & more so recently by some I worked alongside in Iraq, we can all see it  coming, don't wear yourself out trying to educate people. When these things happen if you set yourself up correctly, then we will be able to walk in as the industry here has no idea what it is doing.

Occupational Health at Work

Personally I believe in trying to stop it from happening here & making the place truly safe to live in. To do that you have to ensure the basic security & Health & Safety are taken care off.

                                               http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Health & Safety still Failing.

Kia Ora

No matter what happens, it seems the associated professions of Police officer, Corrections officer or Security officer/guard in this country are not deemed to have to work in line with Health & Safety requirements that all others in the work force are.

It all, as I have said previously, comes back to having a culture of Risk Assessment.

The Police have gone someway towards it in issuing bodyarmour for their staff, but they still have single officers in vehicles when two are required.

Where as the Corrections department think that only some of their staff require bodyarmour & only have to don it under certain circumstances.

It should be, if a correct risk assessment is carried out, that all are required to wear it, unless you can justify not wearing it. You can not say "oh we have it, but at the time it was not seen as neccesary for this task."

No one knows when it is going to be required so you can't  pick & choose when you wear it. Though for each specialist task there needs to be supplied specialist equipment.

Then yet again we get to the  NZ Security Industry where the attitude is there is no way anyone needs bodyarmour, drills are not taught & generally the industry takes the attitude that you must ignore all crime or suspicious activity, unless on your clients property & even that is often on a case by case basis.

International visitors can not believe the clear lack of Health & Safety requirements in most industries in this country.

But every week we are reminded of how low the standards are.

In the professions above there will always a certain amount of danger, the same as the military, but it can be partly mitigated by having again that culture of Risk assessment.

                                    http://www.foxhoundsecurity.co.nz

Friday, May 14, 2010

School Security

Kia Ora,

There has been a few issues with internet of late so delays in getting this blog up to date. Don't you love telecommunications?

One of the recent issues has been that of School security. Though not on the scale of the issues overseas yet, NZ is already well past the nice school yards of yester year.

This week has seen first a school teacher stabbed by a 13 year old & then a 15 year old girl had to be talked down by a teacher after threatening other students with a knife.

One of the issues arising from this has been the schools worrying about the Bill of Rights in regards to any searches of students.

There are certainly precautions that need to be taken, such as females only searched by females, privacy & always having a witness on hand when searching, but in this case I would say that is secondary as it clashes with another law. 

My understanding is Parliament actually set this law(Bill of Rights) up like this.

That other law is Health & Safety, in particular of other students & teachers. Not to mention any security they may employ.

If they don't want to enforce compliance with entry conditions, then a compromise is having security on site during school hours. A minimum of two guards, numbers depending of the size of school, & have them constantly patrolling.

The signs of potential trouble can usually be picked up before it happens when you combine experience & training.

We have to stop being PC & starting imposing rules on the young people of today.

One thing you notice when you have had to deal with or work with teenagers, most of them would actually like some rules.

They are still going to push them, but without any effectively in place either in most school environments or in public they are going to keep doing more outrageous things to get noticed.

In fact experience has shown that most of the worst kids actually like discipline more. Especially if used in channelling their energies in areas where they are more at home other than a classroom.

A few years ago now, as part of the army, we engaged with a boys home. The leader of our training was known throughout the army as a hard task master.

Whilst carrying out some specialist training he used to impose certain punishments & whilst the boys were training with us they got exactly the same punishments.

When we visited their accomodation afterwards they all wanted this leader to see where they lived. In been hard on them, in their minds he actually showed he cared.

Once they leave the school environment it becomes a clash of then expecting not to have any restrictions placed on them & the rules of society.

You see it with the boy racer community here in Christchurch.

They do not believe they are doing anything wrong when using someones property as a toilet, destroying signage & property belonging to businesses & items of public property.
When you confront them over this they are of the belief that you have no right to interfere in what they are doing & they have the right to destroy property.

With the continuing economic downturn & repercussions of it, we are seeing more & more people prepared to take on the authorities.

We have sown the seeds of our coming nightmares.

                                                 http://www.foxhoundsecurity.conz